SRG Care Consultancy graphic about the Supreme Court deprivation of liberty judgment and its impact on care homes, supported living and domiciliary care providers.

Supreme Court Overrules Cheshire West: What Care Providers Need to Know

The Supreme Court has handed down a highly significant judgment on deprivation of liberty, mental capacity and Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The judgment is likely to have important implications for care homes, supported living providers, domiciliary care providers, commissioners, local authorities and professionals involved in Mental Capacity Act assessments, DoLS referrals, restrictive practice and Court of Protection applications.

The case considered what amounts to a “deprivation of liberty” for adults aged 16 and over who lack capacity to make decisions about their residence and care arrangements, particularly where they are living in community settings such as supported living, care homes, private homes or their own homes with care support.

Why This Judgment Matters

Since the 2014 Cheshire West judgment, the commonly applied “acid test” has been whether a person is under continuous supervision and control and is not free to leave. If both parts of that test were met, and the person lacked capacity to consent to the arrangements, the situation was usually treated as a deprivation of liberty.

The Supreme Court has now concluded that the Cheshire West approach was too broad and should be overruled. This is a major development because Cheshire West has shaped deprivation of liberty practice across health and social care for more than a decade.

The judgment does not remove the need for safeguards. It does, however, change the way deprivation of liberty should be assessed.

What Has Changed?

The Supreme Court has confirmed that the correct approach is a wider, multifactorial assessment. This means decision-makers must look at the person’s specific situation as a whole.

Relevant factors may include the type of restrictions in place, the duration of those restrictions, the effect on the person, the way the arrangements are implemented, whether the person objects, whether there is coercion, and whether the person is able to show valid consent through their current wishes and feelings.

This means that a person who lacks legal capacity to make a formal decision about their residence and care arrangements may not automatically be deprived of their liberty simply because they are supervised and would not be allowed to leave alone.

Does This Mean DoLS No Longer Applies?

No. This judgment does not mean that DoLS no longer applies. It also does not mean that care providers can stop making DoLS referrals or Court of Protection applications.

At the time of writing, CQC and local authority operational guidance will need time to respond to the judgment. Providers should therefore continue to follow existing DoLS and Court of Protection processes unless and until updated national or local guidance confirms a different approach.

The judgment recognises that some people who lack legal capacity may still be able to show genuine acceptance of their living arrangements. For example, a person may not have the capacity to fully understand, use and weigh all the relevant information about where they live, but may still be able to communicate, through words, behaviour, signs, gestures, facial expressions or other means, that they are settled, content and accepting of their current home and care arrangements.

However, providers must be extremely careful. There is a clear difference between genuine acceptance and mere compliance. A person may appear settled because they have become used to restrictions, because they do not understand there are alternatives, because they are afraid of the consequences of objecting, because they are masking distress, or because their communication needs have not been properly understood.

A simple statement such as “the person appears happy” will not be enough.

What This Could Mean for Care Homes

For care homes, this judgment is directly relevant because care homes are within the current DoLS framework in England and Wales.

Many residents are currently referred for DoLS authorisation because they lack capacity, are supervised by staff and would not be free to leave the home unaccompanied. Following this judgment, care homes are likely to need a more detailed screening and recording process before deciding whether a DoLS referral is required.

Care homes will need to consider whether the person is genuinely settled in the home, whether they show positive acceptance of the arrangements, whether they object verbally or through their behaviour, whether staff would physically prevent them from leaving, whether doors are locked or exits are restricted, whether restraint or sedation is used, whether the person is subject to continuous observation, whether sensor mats or monitoring equipment are being used, whether there are restrictions on visitors or contact with family, and whether the restrictions are necessary, proportionate and the least restrictive option available.

The key point is that providers will need stronger evidence. It will not be enough to rely on generic wording or assumptions about the person’s presentation.

What This Could Mean for Supported Living

For supported living providers, the judgment may have even greater practical impact.

DoLS does not apply to supported living in England and Wales. Where a person in supported living is deprived of their liberty, authorisation has generally been required through the Court of Protection rather than through the DoLS process.

Following the judgment, there may be fewer cases where Court of Protection authorisation is required, particularly where the person lives in their own tenancy, is genuinely settled, has meaningful routines, is supported to access the community, is not objecting to the arrangements, and is not subject to significant coercive or restrictive practices.

However, supported living providers should not assume that a tenancy means the person is not deprived of their liberty. A person can live in their own home and still be deprived of liberty if the restrictions around them are significant enough.

The focus is not simply on the type of service or the legal status of the accommodation. The focus is on the person’s actual lived experience and the restrictions imposed on them.

Supported living providers delivering regulated personal care should ensure that care plans, risk assessments and Mental Capacity Act records clearly explain the person’s wishes and feelings, how consent or acceptance has been assessed, what restrictions are in place, and whether the arrangements remain necessary and proportionate.

What This Could Mean for Domiciliary Care

For domiciliary care providers, the impact may be less obvious in ordinary care packages, as most standard home care visits will not amount to a deprivation of liberty.

However, the judgment is highly relevant to complex home care packages, especially where a person receives 24-hour care, live-in care or highly restrictive support.

This may include situations where doors are locked, staff prevent the person from leaving, the person is under continuous supervision, there are restrictions on visitors or relationships, medication is used to manage behaviour, covert medication is being administered, physical restraint is used, bed rails or lap belts restrict movement, monitoring technology is used to control the person, or the person is showing distress or resistance to the arrangements.

The fact that care is being delivered in the person’s own home does not automatically mean there is no deprivation of liberty. Providers must consider the reality of the person’s situation, the level of control being exercised, the person’s wishes and feelings, and whether the arrangements are genuinely the least restrictive option.

For domiciliary care providers, this will be particularly important where the care package is commissioned by a local authority or NHS body and involves significant supervision, control or restriction.

Policy and Procedure Implications

From a compliance perspective, providers should not make rushed changes or withdraw existing DoLS applications without proper advice or updated guidance. The safer approach is to continue following existing DoLS and Court of Protection processes until further national and local guidance is issued.

However, providers should start preparing now because this judgment is likely to require changes to policies, care planning documentation, risk assessments, MCA records, restrictive practice records and quality assurance systems.

Mental Capacity Act policies should be reviewed to ensure they accurately reflect the current legal position. Policies should explain that capacity remains decision-specific under the Mental Capacity Act 2005, but that lack of legal capacity does not automatically mean that a person is unable to show valid consent for Article 5 purposes.

DoLS and deprivation of liberty policies should also be reviewed. Providers should avoid relying only on the old Cheshire West acid test as the complete legal position. Policies will need to reflect the broader multifactorial approach confirmed by the Supreme Court, including the importance of the person’s wishes and feelings, the nature of any restrictions, the person’s objections or acceptance, and whether there is serious doubt about consent.

Care Planning and Risk Assessment Implications

Care planning templates should include clearer sections on liberty, restrictions, choice, control, wishes and feelings. Care plans should record how the person communicates, what they appear to understand about their living arrangements, whether they show signs of acceptance or objection, what restrictions are in place, why those restrictions are necessary, what less restrictive alternatives have been considered, and when the arrangements will be reviewed.

Risk assessments should also be strengthened. Where restrictions are used, the provider should be able to evidence why they are necessary, proportionate, in the person’s best interests, and the least restrictive way of managing the identified risk.

Restrictions should not be used for staff convenience, organisational routine or blanket risk management.

Restrictive Practice Implications

Restrictive practice will require particular attention. Providers should audit the use of locked doors, restraint, sedative medication, covert medication, bed rails, lap belts, sensor mats, surveillance or monitoring equipment, restrictions on leaving the home, restrictions on contact with others, and restrictions on access to money, phones or the community.

Any restriction must be lawful, necessary, proportionate, person-centred and kept under review.

This judgment is likely to increase the importance of being able to evidence that restrictions are not simply being accepted as part of the care package, but are actively reviewed and reduced where possible.

Staff Training Implications

Staff training will also need to be updated. Staff must understand that a person not actively objecting is not the same as giving valid consent.

Staff should be trained to recognise non-verbal communication, signs of distress, behavioural indicators, changes in presentation, masking, compliance, fluctuating wishes and the importance of supported decision-making.

This is particularly important for services supporting people with learning disabilities, autism, dementia, acquired brain injury, complex mental health needs or communication difficulties.

CQC Implications

CQC is likely to consider this judgment through several areas of the Single Assessment Framework, including safe care and treatment, safeguarding, consent to care and treatment, person-centred care, independence, choice and control, and governance.

Providers should be able to show that they understand the Mental Capacity Act, recognise restrictions, involve people in decisions, reduce unnecessary restrictions, protect people from unlawful deprivation of liberty, and seek appropriate authorisation where required.

Providers with outdated policies, generic MCA records or poor restrictive practice oversight may find this becomes an area of increased regulatory scrutiny.

What Providers Should Do Now

Providers should not treat this judgment as permission to stop making referrals. Where a person objects, appears distressed, repeatedly tries to leave, is subject to significant restrictions, or where their wishes and feelings are unclear or difficult to interpret, providers should continue to seek appropriate authorisation.

The safest and most compliant approach is to continue current referral processes while reviewing internal systems, strengthening records, auditing restrictive practice and preparing for updated guidance.

Providers should review their Mental Capacity Act policy, DoLS policy, deprivation of liberty procedure, restrictive practice policy, care planning templates, risk assessment templates, MCA assessment records, quality assurance audits and staff training arrangements.

How SRG Can Support

SRG can support care homes, supported living providers and domiciliary care providers to review their current Mental Capacity Act, DoLS, deprivation of liberty, restrictive practice and care planning arrangements in light of this judgment.

We can assist with policy reviews, care planning templates, MCA assessment documentation, restrictive practice audits, quality assurance systems, CQC compliance evidence and staff guidance.

If your service would like support reviewing its current MCA and deprivation of liberty processes, please contact SRG for professional advice and practical compliance support.

Get In Touch

Share this post